Brunello vs Rosso di Montalcino: What's the Difference?

Historic Montalcino – photo by Vural Yavas, Pexels

Brunello di Montalcino and Rosso di Montalcino are both made from 100% Sangiovese grown around the Tuscan town of Montalcino. The big difference is time. Brunello must age for years before release and is built for the cellar. Rosso is younger, fresher and ready to drink sooner, usually at a much friendlier price.

Same grape, same hills

Both wines must be made from the local clone of Sangiovese, called Brunello or Sangiovese Grosso, and both must be produced and bottled in Montalcino. Wine Folly points out that this variety has thick-skinned berries, which tends to give bold fruit, firm tannins and high acidity. That is the backbone of both wines.

Many of the same top producers make both. The grapes may even come from neighbouring vineyards. The difference lies in selection and in the rules that follow the harvest.

The rules in plain English

Here is how the two compare, using figures from Wine Folly and James Suckling:

  • Brunello di Montalcino DOCG needs four years of ageing, including at least two in oak and at least four months in bottle (six for Riserva). It is released from 1 January of the fifth year after harvest. A Riserva comes out a year later, from 1 January of the sixth year. Minimum alcohol is 12.5%.
  • Rosso di Montalcino DOC can be released from 1 September of the year after harvest. There is no oak requirement. Minimum alcohol is 12%.

Note that the two sources describe the Brunello minimum slightly differently (James Suckling counts four years in total with six months in bottle, while Wine Folly mentions four months for the standard wine). Always check the label of a specific bottle, and remember that many producers age their wines for longer than the legal minimum.

How they taste

James Suckling describes Rosso as a fresher, more approachable wine that can be drunk on release. Think red cherry, a little spice and lively acidity. It is a good introduction if you are new to Sangiovese or not yet ready for Brunello's complexity.

Brunello is deeper. After its long ageing you can expect dark fruit, dried herbs, leather and tobacco, with tannins that need food or time. The best bottles keep improving for many years.

The price gap

Brunello costs more because the winery waits years to sell it and uses premium vineyards and barrels. James Suckling notes that Rosso usually costs about half as much, around 20 to 35 US dollars a bottle in the American market. The same logic applies here: you are paying for time and selection.

Interestingly, Poggio Antico's general manager told Suckling that Rosso can be more consistent from year to year, because producers bottle less Brunello in weaker vintages and move that fruit into Rosso instead.

Which one should you open?

  • Midweek dinner, pizza, pasta with meat sauce: Rosso di Montalcino.
  • Sunday roast, game, aged pecorino: Brunello.
  • A gift or a special occasion: Brunello, ideally in a gift box.
  • Trying Montalcino for the first time: start with Rosso, then trade up.

Open a young Brunello at least an hour before serving, or decant it. Serve both at about 16 to 18 °C.

Shop the wines

Sources

Photos: Vural Yavas, Siegfried Poepperl and Claudio Mota via Pexels (free licence)