Prosecco vs Franciacorta vs Champagne: A Simple Guide

Three flutes of sparkling wine – WineTime

The short answer: Prosecco is a fruity, fresh sparkling wine made in a pressurised tank from the Glera grape. Franciacorta and Champagne are both made by the traditional method, with the second fermentation in the bottle, which gives them a richer, toastier character. Franciacorta is Italy's answer to Champagne, from Lombardy.

Where each wine comes from

Champagne comes from northern France, east of Paris. Prosecco is made in north-eastern Italy, mainly in Veneto and Friuli Venezia Giulia. Franciacorta is both the wine and the place: a hilly area in the province of Brescia, in Lombardy, around Lake Iseo, between Venice and Milan.

Climate matters here. Great British Chefs notes that Franciacorta has a warmer microclimate than Champagne, which means riper fruit and, in its words, lower acidity and a fruitier character.

The grapes

  • Prosecco: mainly Glera, which must make up at least 85% of the blend according to Decanter.
  • Franciacorta: Chardonnay, Pinot Noir and Pinot Bianco (Pinot Blanc). Unlike Champagne, there is no Pinot Meunier.
  • Champagne: mostly Pinot Noir, Chardonnay and Pinot Meunier, although eight varieties are allowed in total.

How the bubbles are made

Every sparkling wine needs a second fermentation, which creates the bubbles. The place where it happens changes everything.

Tank method (Prosecco). The second fermentation takes place in a large pressurised tank. It is called the Charmat or Martinotti method. The process keeps the wine fresh and the aromas of pear, apple, honeysuckle and flowers in the spotlight.

Traditional method (Franciacorta and Champagne). The second fermentation happens inside each bottle. The wine is then aged on its lees, riddled, disgorged and topped with a dose of sugar syrup (the dosage). Ageing on dead yeast adds flavours of bread, brioche and toast.

Decanter gives one useful rule for Champagne: non-vintage bottles must spend at least 12 months on the lees plus three more months after disgorgement, and vintage wines at least three years.

A young star from Italy

Prosecco has been made for hundreds of years. Franciacorta is a much younger success story. VinePair says it was first made in 1961. Great British Chefs adds that the area's wines received DOC status in 1967, and sparkling Franciacorta became a DOCG in 1995.

Scale is very different too. In 2017 Champagne sold 315 million bottles, compared with 18.5 million for Franciacorta. That small volume is part of the charm.

What they taste like

  • Prosecco: light, fresh and fruity. Easy to love, and perfect for aperitivo.
  • Franciacorta: drier and more yeasty than Prosecco, with creamy bubbles and a generous, ripe fruit style.
  • Champagne: often more mineral and zesty, with pronounced brioche notes after long ageing.

There is no winner. They simply do different jobs.

What to open and when

Pour Prosecco for parties, brunch and spritz-style aperitivo. Choose Franciacorta for a dinner where you want elegance and body, for example with fish starters, risotto or fried seafood. Satèn, a softer style, is particularly graceful. Pick Champagne when you want that classic toasted depth, or when a celebration calls for a famous label.

Shop the wines

Sources

Photo: Main image: AI illustration for WineTime · Gallery: Nati, Bent Vermeiren and Rene Terp via Pexels (free licence)