A Super Tuscan is a Tuscan red wine that broke the traditional rules. It usually uses grapes such as Cabernet Sauvignon or Merlot, either alone or blended with Sangiovese, and it often ages in small French oak barrels. The name is informal. There is no legal definition, which is exactly why the story is so interesting.
Why the rebels needed a new name
In the 1960s, much Tuscan wine was simple and sharp. The new DOC system was created to lift quality and reputation. But the Chianti rules of the time asked for a recipe that included white grapes, such as Trebbiano and Malvasia, and did not allow a pure Sangiovese wine.
Some ambitious producers wanted to make something different. Their wines did not fit the rules, so they had to be sold under the humblest label, vino da tavola, or table wine. Ironically, these "table wines" became some of the most expensive bottles in Italy.
The key moments
- 1944: Mario Incisa della Rocchetta plants Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc at Tenuta San Guido near Bolgheri. Sassicaia is born from that idea. VinePair says the 1968 vintage was the first, and it reached the market in 1971.
- 1971: Antinori's Tignanello, a Sangiovese-led wine with Cabernet, appears. Because it left out white grapes, it was classified as table wine.
- 1978: A blind tasting of Bordeaux-style blends is won by a 1972 Sassicaia, according to VinePair. Winefriend notes that the result put the wine ahead of Bordeaux first growths.
- 1985: Ornellaia releases its first Bordeaux-style wine. Robert Parker gives the 1985 Sassicaia 100 points, per both Wine Folly and Winefriend. The term Super Tuscan is probably first used in print in the same year, by Nicolas Belfrage.
How the law caught up
The IGT category arrived in 1992 and became the home for most Super Tuscans. Bolgheri received DOC status in 1994, and Sassicaia got its own appellation, Bolgheri Sassicaia DOC. Winefriend adds that in 1996 the Chianti rules were changed: white grapes became optional and a 100% Sangiovese wine was allowed.
Today the main labels you will see are:
- Toscana IGT, the most common one.
- Bolgheri DOC, for the coastal area where Cabernet and Merlot thrive.
- Maremma Toscana DOC, for southern Tuscany.
Three styles of Super Tuscan
- Bordeaux blends, based on Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot and Cabernet Franc. More recently Syrah has joined them.
- Sangiovese with a Bordeaux grape, such as Tignanello.
- Pure Sangiovese wines that were rejected by Chianti rules, like Montevertine's Le Pergole Torte, first made in 1977.
French oak barriques are common across all three, replacing the larger traditional barrels. Winefriend credits Giacomo Tachis, who worked with the Antinori family, for promoting them.
How to spot one
Look for a proprietary name on the label, such as Tignanello, Ornellaia or Sassicaia, rather than a classic Chianti or Brunello name. Wine Folly says the invented name usually signals a proprietary blend or a single-variety wine. Check the appellation line to see whether it says Toscana IGT, Bolgheri or Maremma.
Serving tips
Decant young bottles for an hour or two. Serve at 16 to 18 °C with grilled steak, roast lamb, wild boar ragu or aged cheese.